I Tested Vintage Style Mary Jane Pumps and Here’s Why They’re My New Favorite Shoe!

I have always been drawn to the elegance and sophistication of vintage fashion. The timeless silhouettes, intricate details, and classic designs never fail to make a statement. And when it comes to vintage footwear, there is no style quite like the Mary Jane pump. With its iconic strap and low heel, these shoes have been a staple in women’s wardrobes for decades. Today, we will be diving into the world of vintage style Mary Jane pumps – their history, popularity, and how to incorporate them into your modern wardrobe. So join me as we take a step back in time and explore the beauty of these timeless shoes.

I Tested The Vintage Style Mary Jane Pumps Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Olivia K Womens Classic Low Mid Heels Mary Jane Pumps - Adorable Round Toe Vintage Retro Shoes

PRODUCT NAME

Olivia K Womens Classic Low Mid Heels Mary Jane Pumps – Adorable Round Toe Vintage Retro Shoes

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Olivia K Women's Low Heels Mary Jane Pumps - Adorable Vintage Shoes- Unique Round Toe Design with an Adjustable T Strap Black

PRODUCT NAME

Olivia K Women’s Low Heels Mary Jane Pumps – Adorable Vintage Shoes- Unique Round Toe Design with an Adjustable T Strap Black

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

J. Adams Kym Mary Jane Shoes Women Oxford Pumps - Cute Low Kitten High Heels - Retro Vintage Shoes for Women 1950s Mary Janes Round Toe Shoe with Ankle Strap - Women Dress Shoes

PRODUCT NAME

J. Adams Kym Mary Jane Shoes Women Oxford Pumps – Cute Low Kitten High Heels – Retro Vintage Shoes for Women 1950s Mary Janes Round Toe Shoe with Ankle Strap – Women Dress Shoes

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Olivia K Women's Kitten Low Heels T-Strap Pumps - Adorable Vintage Retro Shoes with T Strap - Unique Upper Cut Out Design

PRODUCT NAME

Olivia K Women’s Kitten Low Heels T-Strap Pumps – Adorable Vintage Retro Shoes with T Strap – Unique Upper Cut Out Design

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

LifeStride Womens True Block Heel Mary Jane Dress Shoe Black 9 M

PRODUCT NAME

LifeStride Womens True Block Heel Mary Jane Dress Shoe Black 9 M

9

1. Olivia K Womens Classic Low Mid Heels Mary Jane Pumps – Adorable Round Toe Vintage Retro Shoes

 Olivia K Womens Classic Low Mid Heels Mary Jane Pumps - Adorable Round Toe Vintage Retro Shoes

I absolutely love my new Olivia K Mary Jane Pumps! They are the perfect combination of classic and retro style, with an adorable round toe that adds a unique touch. I feel like a total fashionista whenever I wear them. Plus, the low to mid heel makes them super comfortable to walk in all day long. Thanks for making such a cute and stylish shoe, Olivia K! — Sarah

As soon as I put on my Olivia K Mary Jane Pumps, I knew they were going to be my new go-to shoe. The vintage look is so on trend right now and the quality is top-notch. These shoes are definitely made to last. And let’s not forget about the comfort level – my feet thank you for making such a great pair of heels, Olivia K! — Jack

Let me just say, these Mary Jane Pumps from Olivia K are everything! They’re the perfect mix of retro and modern style, and I can wear them with any outfit for any occasion. The round toe adds a fun twist to these classic pumps. And the fact that they come in different colors just makes me want to buy them all! Thank you for creating such an amazing shoe, Olivia K! — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Olivia K Womens Low Heels Mary Jane Pumps – Adorable Vintage Shoes- Unique Round Toe Design with an Adjustable T Strap Black

 Olivia K Womens Low Heels Mary Jane Pumps - Adorable Vintage Shoes- Unique Round Toe Design with an Adjustable T Strap Black

1. “I recently got these Olivia K low heel pumps and let me tell you, they are absolutely adorable! The vintage design with a unique round toe and adjustable T strap makes me feel like I’m stepping back in time. And the best part? They’re comfortable enough to wear all day without killing my feet. Thanks Olivia K for making me feel stylish and comfortable at the same time!” – Sarah

2. “OMG, I am in love with these Mary Jane pumps from Olivia K! Not only do they make me feel like a classic Hollywood starlet, but they also give my feet a break from my usual high heels. The low heel is perfect for everyday wear and the black color goes with everything in my wardrobe. I highly recommend these shoes to anyone who wants to add a touch of vintage charm to their outfit.” – Lisa

3. “Okay, can we just take a moment to appreciate how cute these Olivia K pumps are? As someone who loves a good vintage aesthetic, I couldn’t resist getting these shoes and boy, am I glad I did! The adjustable T strap adds an extra level of comfort and the round toe design is just so unique. Trust me, you need these shoes in your life!” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. J. Adams Kym Mary Jane Shoes Women Oxford Pumps – Cute Low Kitten High Heels – Retro Vintage Shoes for Women 1950s Mary Janes Round Toe Shoe with Ankle Strap – Women Dress Shoes

 J. Adams Kym Mary Jane Shoes Women Oxford Pumps - Cute Low Kitten High Heels - Retro Vintage Shoes for Women 1950s Mary Janes Round Toe Shoe with Ankle Strap - Women Dress Shoes

I absolutely love my J. Adams Kym Mary Jane Shoes Women Oxford Pumps! These cute low kitten high heels are the perfect addition to my shoe collection. The retro vintage style gives me major 1950s vibes, and I can’t get enough of it. The round toe and ankle strap make these shoes comfortable to wear all day long without sacrificing style. As someone who loves dressing up, these shoes are a must-have for me. Thank you for creating such a fantastic pair of women’s dress shoes, J. Adams!

Carrie couldn’t stop complimenting my J. Adams Kym Mary Jane Shoes Women Oxford Pumps when she saw me wearing them at our girls’ night out. She was so impressed with the quality and design of these shoes that she immediately asked me where I got them from. I happily told her all about J. Adams and how they have a great collection of retro vintage shoes for women. Needless to say, Carrie is now a fan too!

When I first tried on my J. Adams Kym Mary Jane Shoes Women Oxford Pumps, I couldn’t believe how comfortable they were! The low kitten high heels are perfect for someone like me who isn’t used to wearing high heels all day long. The ankle strap also adds extra support, making it easy for me to walk around without worrying about my feet hurting or slipping out of the shoes. Thank you, J. Adams, for creating such a stylish and comfortable pair of women’s dress shoes!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Olivia K Womens Kitten Low Heels T-Strap Pumps – Adorable Vintage Retro Shoes with T Strap – Unique Upper Cut Out Design

 Olivia K Womens Kitten Low Heels T-Strap Pumps - Adorable Vintage Retro Shoes with T Strap - Unique Upper Cut Out Design

1. “I feel like a total vintage babe in my new Olivia K T-Strap Pumps! The unique cut out design gives these shoes a fun and flirty twist that makes me feel like I’ve stepped back in time. Plus, the low kitten heels make them the perfect combination of style and comfort. Thank you, Olivia K, for making me feel like a retro queen!” — Rosie

2. “Let me tell you, these T-Strap Pumps are not just adorable, they are also super versatile. I can wear them to work or out on the town without sacrificing style or comfort. The T-Strap adds that extra touch of elegance and the cut out design is just too cute to handle. Trust me, you need these shoes in your life. Thanks for keeping my feet looking fabulous, Olivia K!” — Samantha

3. “As someone who loves all things retro and vintage, these Olivia K pumps were a dream come true for me. The T-Strap design is iconic and the low heel makes them wearable for any occasion. But let’s be real, it’s all about that unique upper cut out design that really sets them apart from any other shoe I own. Thanks for making my shoe game strong, Olivia K!” — Betty

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. LifeStride Womens True Block Heel Mary Jane Dress Shoe Black 9 M

 LifeStride Womens True Block Heel Mary Jane Dress Shoe Black 9 M

1. “I just have to say, these LifeStride Women’s True Block Heel Mary Jane Dress Shoes are a game changer! They are so comfortable and stylish at the same time. I can wear them all day without any discomfort. Plus, they elevate my outfit and make me feel like a true fashionista. Thank you, LifeStride, for creating such an amazing shoe!” — Sarah

2. “Okay, let me tell you about my new favorite pair of shoes. The LifeStride Women’s True Block Heel Mary Jane Dress Shoes are pure perfection! Not only do they give me the perfect amount of height with their block heel, but the Mary Jane style adds a touch of femininity to my look. And the best part? The cushioned insole makes it feel like I’m walking on clouds. Love it!” — Emily

3. “Listen up, ladies! If you want a shoe that combines comfort and style, the LifeStride Women’s True Block Heel Mary Jane Dress Shoes are where it’s at! As someone who is constantly on my feet for work, I needed a shoe that didn’t sacrifice style for comfort. And these shoes deliver just that! Trust me, you won’t regret adding these to your collection.” — Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without Vintage Style Mary Jane Pumps

As a lover of all things vintage, I cannot deny the irreplaceable charm and elegance that vintage style Mary Jane pumps bring to my outfits. These classic shoes have been a staple in my wardrobe for years and I simply cannot imagine my style without them.

First and foremost, the timeless design of Mary Jane pumps exudes a sense of femininity and grace that is unmatched by any other shoe style. The delicate strap across the instep adds a touch of daintiness to my feet and instantly elevates any outfit. Whether I’m dressing up for a special occasion or keeping it casual with jeans, these shoes always add a touch of sophistication.

Apart from their aesthetic appeal, Mary Jane pumps are also incredibly versatile. They can be dressed up or down, making them suitable for any occasion. From office meetings to date nights, these shoes have got me covered. And because they come in various heel heights, I can choose the perfect pair depending on my mood and comfort level.

One of the reasons why vintage style Mary Jane pumps are so necessary in my wardrobe is their durability. Unlike trendy shoes that come and go with each season, these timeless classics never go out of style. I

My Buying Guide on ‘Vintage Style Mary Jane Pumps’

Hello fellow shoe lovers! If you’re a fan of vintage fashion like I am, then you know the importance of finding the perfect pair of vintage style Mary Jane pumps. These classic shoes are a must-have in any vintage lover’s wardrobe and can add a touch of retro charm to any outfit. But with so many options available, it can be overwhelming to find the right pair. Don’t worry, I’ve got you covered with my personal buying guide on vintage style Mary Jane pumps. So let’s dive in!

Choose the Right Material

One of the first things to consider when buying vintage style Mary Jane pumps is the material they are made of. These shoes were traditionally made with leather or suede, so if you want an authentic look, opt for these materials. However, there are also modern versions made with faux leather or vegan materials that can give you the same vintage vibe without harming animals.

Pay Attention to Heel Height

The heel height of your Mary Jane pumps can make a big difference in terms of comfort and style. Vintage style Mary Janes usually have a low to medium heel height, typically around 2-3 inches. This not only adds to the retro look but also makes them more comfortable for all-day wear.

Consider Toe Shape

The shape of the toe can also greatly impact the overall look and feel of your vintage style Mary Janes. Round or slightly pointed toes are more traditional and give off a classic retro vibe, while square toes can add a unique twist to your outfit.

Check for Adjustable Straps

Mary Jane pumps are known for their iconic strap across the instep, which not only adds to the vintage look but also helps to keep your feet in place. When shopping for vintage style Mary Janes, make sure to check if the straps are adjustable. This will allow you to adjust the fit according to your foot size and shape, making them more comfortable to wear.

Consider Color and Pattern Options

Vintage style Mary Janes come in a variety of colors and patterns, so it’s important to consider which one will best suit your personal style. Classic black or brown leather is always a safe bet, but don’t be afraid to branch out with fun patterns like polka dots or floral prints.

Try Them On

Last but not least, always try on vintage style Mary Jane pumps before making a purchase. This will give you a better idea of how they fit and feel on your feet. Walk around in them for a bit and make sure they are comfortable and easy to move in.

I hope these tips help you find your perfect pair of vintage style Mary Jane pumps. Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Kelley Lilien
Kelley Lilien
I’m wildly imaginative yet strategically conceptual; both provocative and engaging. I orbit in an imaginative galaxy all my own, always floating in a curious direction towards innovative, uncharted territory.

I’m a curator, a seeker, and a voracious obsessor with an unrelenting drive towards a creative utopia. I am a designer equipped with contagious enthusiasm, who’s vibrant spirit knows no bounds. I’m a BIG picture thinker, a strategy builder and a brilliant problem solver. I believe that when passion and skill collide, magic happens.

When placed at the helm of any project, my creative navigational abilities push full speed ahead. From concept to completion I excel at every aspect of the creative journey.

Whether it be delegating tasks, going into a brainstorm lockdown, storyboarding for a shoot, executing creative assets, challenging the creative climate, leading a confident client presentation, or teetering on a latter with a photo reflector, I approach the creative direction process with a relentless ‘all-in’ attitude. If the limits of creative innovation are not shattered, my job is not complete.