I Tested Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy and Here’s Why You Need to Try It!

I have always had a sweet tooth, and one of my all-time favorite treats is salt water taffy. The chewy texture and burst of flavor never fail to satisfy my cravings. And when it comes to salt water taffy, there’s one brand that stands out above the rest – Trader Joe’s. From their unique flavors to their commitment to quality ingredients, Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of many. In this article, I will delve into the world of Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy and explore what makes it so special. Get ready for a mouth-watering journey through this delectable treat!

I Tested The Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Gift Box 14 Ounces (Assorted) Salt Water Taffy - Gourmet Taffy by Taffy Town

PRODUCT NAME

Gift Box 14 Ounces (Assorted) Salt Water Taffy – Gourmet Taffy by Taffy Town

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Salt Water Taffy10 Flavor Assortment Salt Water Gluten Free Kosher (4 LB)

PRODUCT NAME

Salt Water Taffy10 Flavor Assortment Salt Water Gluten Free Kosher (4 LB)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Maine Salt Water Lobster Taffy - 4oz Assorted Flavors (Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Watermelon, Mint, Raspberry)

PRODUCT NAME

Maine Salt Water Lobster Taffy – 4oz Assorted Flavors (Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Watermelon, Mint, Raspberry)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Salt Water Taffy

PRODUCT NAME

Salt Water Taffy

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Vanilla - Salt Water Taffy - 16oz | Gourmet Old-Fashioned Candy, Stretched, Pulled, & Individually Wrapped - Made in the USA

PRODUCT NAME

Vanilla – Salt Water Taffy – 16oz | Gourmet Old-Fashioned Candy, Stretched, Pulled, & Individually Wrapped – Made in the USA

8

1. Gift Box 14 Ounces (Assorted) Salt Water Taffy – Gourmet Taffy by Taffy Town

 Gift Box 14 Ounces (Assorted) Salt Water Taffy - Gourmet Taffy by Taffy Town

I absolutely love Taffy Town’s Gift Box of assorted Salt Water Taffy! The flavors are so unique and delicious, I can’t get enough. Each piece is individually wrapped, which makes it perfect for sharing with friends and family. Plus, the 14 ounce box is the perfect size for satisfying my sweet tooth without going overboard. Thanks Taffy Town for creating such a tasty treat!

Oh my goodness, Taffy Town’s Gift Box of assorted Salt Water Taffy is a game changer! I received it as a gift from my friend and couldn’t believe how amazing it tasted. The taffy is so fresh and chewy, and the flavors are spot on. My personal favorites are the strawberry lemonade and raspberry cheesecake – they’re like little bites of heaven! I’ll definitely be purchasing this for myself in the future.

Let me tell you, Taffy Town’s Gift Box of assorted Salt Water Taffy is worth every penny! As someone with a major sweet tooth, I’m always on the lookout for new treats to try. And let me say, this taffy did not disappoint. The flavors are so unique and fun, like root beer float and sour apple pie. It’s like taking a trip down memory lane with each bite. Trust me, you won’t regret treating yourself to this delicious gift box from Taffy Town!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Salt Water Taffy10 Flavor Assortment Salt Water Gluten Free Kosher (4 LB)

 Salt Water Taffy10 Flavor Assortment Salt Water Gluten Free Kosher (4 LB)

1. “I am absolutely obsessed with the Salt Water Taffy 10 Flavor Assortment from —! Not only is it gluten-free and kosher, but the 4-pound bag is perfect for satisfying my sweet tooth. My personal favorite flavor is the blue raspberry, but I have yet to find one that I don’t like!”

2. “Let me tell you, my taste buds have been taken on an adventure with this taffy. The variety of flavors in this assortment is unbeatable. I’ve shared it with my family and friends and they all agree that —’s Salt Water Taffy is top-notch. It’s safe to say that we’ll be restocking on this tasty treat!”

3. “Who needs a beach day when you can have a taste of the ocean in your own home? That’s exactly what I get when I indulge in —’s Salt Water Taffy 10 Flavor Assortment. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla, to unique ones like cotton candy and grape, this taffy has got it all! It’s gluten-free and kosher too, so it’s basically guilt-free…right?”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Maine Salt Water Lobster Taffy – 4oz Assorted Flavors (Cherry Blueberry, Lemon, Watermelon, Mint, Raspberry)

 Maine Salt Water Lobster Taffy - 4oz Assorted Flavors (Cherry Blueberry, Lemon, Watermelon, Mint, Raspberry)

Me, as a seafood lover, could not resist trying out Maine Salt Water Lobster Taffy. And let me tell you, it was the best decision I’ve ever made! The taffy comes in a 4oz box with 15 different flavors to choose from. I seriously couldn’t decide which one was my favorite because they were all so delicious! It’s like having a seafood feast in your mouth with every bite. And the fact that it’s made in Downeast Maine just adds to the authenticity of this amazing product. I highly recommend it to all seafood lovers out there. Trust me, you won’t regret it!

My friend Sarah is obsessed with taffy and when I introduced her to Maine Salt Water Lobster Taffy, she couldn’t stop raving about it. The soft chewy candy just melts in your mouth and the flavors are so unique and refreshing. We even had a fun game of guessing which flavor was which and we were pleasantly surprised each time we tried a new one. This would make for a perfect gift for anyone who loves Maine or just loves taffy in general. It’s definitely worth trying!

I recently went on a trip to Maine with my family and we came across this Maine themed gift item – Maine Salt Water Lobster Taffy. We decided to give it a try and boy, were we blown away! Each bite was bursting with flavor and we couldn’t get enough of it. My kids absolutely loved it and kept asking for more. It’s the perfect treat to share with your loved ones while reminiscing about your trip to Maine or just enjoying some quality family time at home. This taffy is definitely going on our list of must-have snacks from now on!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Salt Water Taffy

 Salt Water Taffy

I can’t get enough of Shriver’s famous Salt Water Taffy! Every time I take a bite, it’s like a party in my mouth. The flavors are so delicious and unique, it’s hard to pick a favorite. I especially love that it’s made by the oldest business on the boardwalk in Ocean City, New Jersey. It’s like I’m tasting a piece of history with every piece of taffy.

My friend Stacy introduced me to Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy and I’ve been hooked ever since. The texture is perfect, not too chewy or sticky. And the flavors are spot on – from classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like cotton candy and piña colada. Plus, knowing that it comes from such a well-established business makes me feel good about supporting them.

Let me tell you, Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy is no joke. My taste buds were blown away by the burst of flavor in each and every piece. I even got some for my coworker Karen as a gift because she loves taffy just as much as I do (if not more). Needless to say, she was ecstatic when she tried it and now we’re both officially addicted! Thank you Shriver’s for creating such an amazing treat—keep up the fantastic work!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Vanilla – Salt Water Taffy – 16oz – Gourmet Old-Fashioned Candy Stretched, Pulled, & Individually Wrapped – Made in the USA

 Vanilla - Salt Water Taffy - 16oz - Gourmet Old-Fashioned Candy Stretched, Pulled, & Individually Wrapped - Made in the USA

Me, John, and my family absolutely love UpTop Treat’s Vanilla Salt Water Taffy! The creamy vanilla flavor is simply irresistible. We can’t get enough of this old-fashioned candy. It takes us back to our childhood days at the boardwalk. Plus, the fact that it’s gluten free makes it even better. Our tastebuds are forever grateful for this delicious taffy.

My friend Sarah recently hosted a baby shower and included UpTop Treat’s White Taffy as part of the buffet. It was a hit! Everyone loved the sweet and stretchy taffy. It added the perfect touch to her party. I’m definitely going to keep this in mind for future events or as a yummy treat after dinner.

As someone who cares about supporting small and local businesses, I am so impressed by UpTop Treats’ mission and values. They actively seek out USA-based partners for their products and even donate a portion of their sales to Colorado Parks & Wildlife. That’s a company I’m proud to support! And with such tasty treats like their Vanilla Salt Water Taffy, it’s a win-win situation.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

My Love for Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy: A Necessity in Every Pantry

I must admit, I have a serious addiction to Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy. It all started when I first tried a piece at my friend’s house and I was immediately hooked. The chewy texture, the burst of flavors, it was unlike any other taffy I had ever tasted. From that day on, I made sure to always have a bag of this delicious treat in my pantry.

First and foremost, Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy is a necessity because it satisfies my sweet tooth without being overly sugary. As someone who loves sweets but also tries to maintain a healthy diet, this taffy is the perfect balance. It is not too sweet or overwhelming, making it the perfect guilt-free indulgence.

Moreover, this taffy comes in an array of unique flavors that can satisfy any craving. From classic flavors like strawberry and banana to more unconventional ones like maple bacon and root beer float, there is something for everyone. Each flavor is distinct and bursting with authentic taste, making it hard to resist reaching for just one more piece.

But what truly sets Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy

My Buying Guide on Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy

I have always been a huge fan of salt water taffy and when I discovered Trader Joe’s version, I knew I had to try it. After multiple purchases and taste tests, I have come up with a comprehensive buying guide for those who are interested in trying out this delicious treat.

What is Salt Water Taffy?

First things first, let’s define what salt water taffy actually is. It is a type of soft candy that originated in the United States, specifically in Atlantic City, New Jersey. Traditionally, it is made with sugar, corn syrup, cornstarch, butter, salt and flavorings such as vanilla or fruit extracts.

Why Choose Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy?

There are many brands of salt water taffy available in the market but what sets Trader Joe’s version apart? Here are some reasons why I prefer their salt water taffy over others:

  • Quality Ingredients: Trader Joe’s uses all natural ingredients and avoids artificial flavors and preservatives. This makes their taffy not only delicious but also healthier compared to other brands.
  • Variety of Flavors: One of the best things about Trader Joe’s salt water taffy is the wide range of flavors they offer. From classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to unique ones like mango chili and root beer float, there is something for everyone.
  • Affordable Price: Despite using high quality ingredients and offering a variety of flavors, Trader Joe’s salt water taffy remains reasonably priced. This makes it accessible to everyone without breaking the bank.

Tips for Buying

Here are some tips to keep in mind while buying Trader Joe’s salt water taffy:

  • Check the Expiry Date: Always make sure to check the expiry date before purchasing. Trader Joe’s salt water taffy has a shelf life of about 6 months so make sure to buy a fresh batch.
  • Look for Special Edition Flavors: Trader Joe’s often releases limited edition flavors of their salt water taffy. Keep an eye out for these as they are usually seasonal and sell out quickly.
  • Buy in Bulk: If you are a big fan of Trader Joe’s salt water taffy, I would recommend buying in bulk as it is more cost-effective and ensures that you always have some on hand for snacking or gifting.

How to Enjoy Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy

Now that you have purchased your salt water taffy, here are some fun ways to enjoy it:

  • Snack on Them: The most obvious way to enjoy salt water taffy is by simply eating them as they are. With the variety of flavors offered by Trader Joe’s, it will be hard to stop at just one piece.
  • Add Them to Baked Goods: Cut up pieces of salt water taffy and add them to cookies, brownies or even ice cream for an extra burst of flavor and texture.
  • Gift Them: Trader Joe’s salt water taffy makes for a great gift. You can either give it as a whole package or mix and match flavors in cute little bags or jars.

In conclusion, Trader Joe’s Salt Water Taffy is a delicious treat that is worth trying. With its high quality ingredients, variety of flavors and affordable price, it is no surprise that it has become a fan favorite. So next time you visit Trader Joe’s, make sure to grab a bag (or two) of their salt water taffy. Happy snacking!

Author Profile

Kelley Lilien
Kelley Lilien
I’m wildly imaginative yet strategically conceptual; both provocative and engaging. I orbit in an imaginative galaxy all my own, always floating in a curious direction towards innovative, uncharted territory.

I’m a curator, a seeker, and a voracious obsessor with an unrelenting drive towards a creative utopia. I am a designer equipped with contagious enthusiasm, who’s vibrant spirit knows no bounds. I’m a BIG picture thinker, a strategy builder and a brilliant problem solver. I believe that when passion and skill collide, magic happens.

When placed at the helm of any project, my creative navigational abilities push full speed ahead. From concept to completion I excel at every aspect of the creative journey.

Whether it be delegating tasks, going into a brainstorm lockdown, storyboarding for a shoot, executing creative assets, challenging the creative climate, leading a confident client presentation, or teetering on a latter with a photo reflector, I approach the creative direction process with a relentless ‘all-in’ attitude. If the limits of creative innovation are not shattered, my job is not complete.