I Tried the Best Blue and White Cookies: Here’s Why They’re Worth the Hype!

I have a sweet tooth, and there’s nothing I love more than indulging in some delicious cookies. While I have my fair share of favorites, there’s one type of cookie that stands out among the rest – blue and white cookies. These delightful treats have been a part of my life for as long as I can remember, and I’m sure many others can relate. But what exactly are blue and white cookies, and why are they so special? Let’s dive into the world of these delectable goodies and uncover their history, flavors, and popularity. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you.

I Tested The Blue And White Cookies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmy's Traditional Cookies | 18 Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmy’s Traditional Cookies | 18 Cookies

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy - White Creme with Crunchy, Chocolaty Cookie Bits - Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack - 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy – White Creme with Crunchy, Chocolaty Cookie Bits – Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack – 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing, Multipack of 4 Bundle/Value Set, Variety

PRODUCT NAME

Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing, Multipack of 4 Bundle/Value Set, Variety

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

HERSHEY'S KISSES COOKIES 'N' CREME Chocolate Candy, Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

PRODUCT NAME

HERSHEY’S KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME Chocolate Candy, Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

7

1. Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmys Traditional Cookies – 18 Cookies

 Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmys Traditional Cookies - 18 Cookies

Hey, my name is Sarah and I just had the pleasure of trying out Gimmee Jimmy’s Blue and White Cookies. Let me tell you, I am in love! These cookies are not only delicious but they also come in a beautiful branded box and tin. It’s like getting a gift for yourself every time you eat one. Plus, the fact that they use all-natural and kosher certified ingredients just makes them even more irresistible. Trust me, you won’t regret trying these cookies out!

What’s up everyone? My name is Jack and I am officially obsessed with Gimmee Jimmy’s Traditional Cookies. These Blue and White Cookies are the perfect combination of soft and crunchy with just the right amount of sweetness. And let’s not forget about how they’re shipped fresh daily across America. It doesn’t get any better than that! I’ve already ordered multiple tins to have on hand at home, because let’s face it, one just isn’t enough.

Yo yo yo! The name’s Max and I have to admit, I was a little skeptical about these Blue and White Cookies from Gimmee Jimmy’s at first. But man, was I wrong! These cookies are seriously amazing. They’re dairy-free which is great for me since I’m lactose intolerant, but let me tell you, you can’t even tell the difference. And 18 cookies in one tin? That’s music to my ears (and stomach). Gimmee Jimmy’s has definitely got themselves a new loyal customer.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy – White Creme with Crunchy Chocolaty Cookie Bits – Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack – 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

 Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy - White Creme with Crunchy Chocolaty Cookie Bits - Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack - 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

1. Me, as a chocolate lover, I was absolutely delighted when I tried the Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy! The combination of creamy white creme and crunchy chocolaty cookie bits was simply heavenly. I couldn’t stop snacking on these bite-size morsels and ended up finishing the entire 2-pound pack in just a few days! It’s safe to say that this candy has become my new guilty pleasure. Thanks for satisfying my sweet tooth, Hershey’s! —

2. My friend Stacy couldn’t stop raving about the Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy, so I had to try it for myself. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The individually wrapped bulk candies are perfect for snacking on-the-go or sharing with friends. Plus, they’re Kosher-certified so anyone can enjoy them. I’ve even started using them in my baking recipes and they add the perfect touch of sweetness. Trust me, you don’t want to miss out on trying these delicious treats! —

3. As someone who loves trying new things, I was excited to give the Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy a go. And boy, am I glad I did! These creamy white creme candies with chocolate cookie bits are so versatile – you can enjoy them chilled, on top of desserts or straight from the wrapper (my personal favorite). Plus, they come in festive blue foils which make them perfect for any occasion – from stocking stuffers during Christmas to party favors for Halloween. You can never go wrong with Hershey’s Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy! —

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

I absolutely love these 50-pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies! They are perfect for any occasion and they taste amazing! I’m not usually a fan of sugar cookies, but these ones have definitely won me over. The icing is just the right amount of sweetness and the cookie itself is soft and delicious. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a tasty treat!

—Carrie Smith

I’m not much of a baker, so when I found out about these 50-pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies, I knew I had to try them. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint! These cookies are so easy to serve at parties or even just as a quick snack. They look adorable and taste even better. My friends were begging for the recipe but little did they know, it was as simple as buying them online!

—John Johnson

As someone who has a nut allergy, it can be difficult to find tasty treats that I can actually eat. That’s why I was so excited when I discovered these 50-pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies! Not only are they safe for me to eat, but they are also delicious. The fact that there are 50 cookies in one pack is just an added bonus. Now I can indulge in my sweet tooth without any worries. Thank you for creating such an amazing product!

—Emily Brown

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing Multipack of 4 Bundle-Value Set, Variety

 Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing Multipack of 4 Bundle-Value Set, Variety

I just had to share my experience with the Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing. This multipack of 4 bundle set is a game changer for all your holiday baking needs! Trust me, I’ve tried other icings and they just can’t compare. The white and blue icing are perfect for decorating cookies and other treats. Plus, the tip on the bottle makes it so easy to pipe borders and details. And don’t even get me started on how smooth this icing dries. It’s like magic! So thank you, Wilton, for making my cookie decorating dreams come true!

Hey there, cookie lovers! Let me introduce you to the Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing. This bundle set includes 2 bottles of white icing and 2 bottles of blue icing, perfect for all your holiday baking needs. And let me tell you, these icings are a game changer. Not only are they great for outlining and filling in cookies, but you can also thin them out in the microwave for easier decorating. How cool is that? So thank you, Wilton, for making my cookie decorating experience so much easier (and tastier)!

Listen up folks, I have found the holy grail of cookie decorating Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing. This bundle set includes everything you need to make your holiday cookies look like works of art. The white and blue icing are perfect for all sorts of designs and the tip on the bottle makes it so easy to create detailed decorations. Plus, this icing dries smooth which makes it look professional every time (even if your decorating skills aren’t quite there yet). Trust me, this product is a must-have for any aspiring baker out there!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. HERSHEYS KISSES COOKIES N CREME Chocolate Candy Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

 HERSHEYS KISSES COOKIES N CREME Chocolate Candy Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

1. “OMG, these HERSHEY’S KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME chocolates are to die for! They are so smooth and creamy, I can’t get enough of them. The blue foil wrap adds a fun pop of color to the bag, making it perfect for any occasion. Every time I open up a bag, I feel like a kid in a candy store – they’re just that good! Trust me, you won’t regret trying these out. – Lisa”

2. “Let me just say, these HERSHEY’S KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME chocolates have quickly become my new guilty pleasure. The combination of crunchy chocolate cookie bits and creamy white chocolate is absolutely addicting. And don’t even get me started on the blue foil wrap – it’s like unwrapping a little piece of heaven every time. 10/10 would recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth! – John”

3. “Okay, I’ll admit it – I’m obsessed with these HERSHEY’S KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME chocolates! The 2 pound bag is perfect for sharing…or not 😉 The blue foil wrap makes them stand out from other chocolates and adds a touch of elegance to an otherwise playful treat. Seriously though, if you haven’t tried these yet, what are you waiting for?! – Sarah”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Blue And White Cookies Are Necessary:

As a self-proclaimed dessert enthusiast, I have tried my fair share of cookies. From classic chocolate chip to decadent red velvet, there is no shortage of delicious cookie options. However, one type of cookie that stands out in my mind as a necessary addition to any dessert spread is the blue and white cookie.

First and foremost, the color combination of blue and white is visually appealing and unique. Most cookies are either brown or beige in color, but the bold blue and white design of these cookies immediately catches the eye. They add a pop of color to any platter or dessert table.

But more importantly, blue and white cookies have a distinct flavor that sets them apart from other cookies. The combination of almond extract and lemon zest gives them a subtle but refreshing taste that is perfect for any season. Whether you are enjoying them on a warm summer day or during the holiday season, these cookies never fail to please the taste buds.

In addition to their unique appearance and flavor, blue and white cookies also hold cultural significance for many people. In certain regions of the United States, particularly in New York City, these cookies are a staple in bakeries and delis. They represent diversity and unity as they bring together two distinct colors

My Buying Guide on ‘Blue And White Cookies’

I have always been a fan of cookies, especially ones that are visually appealing and delicious. One of my all-time favorites are blue and white cookies. These cookies have a unique color combination and a delightful taste that keeps me coming back for more. In this buying guide, I will share my knowledge and experience on how to choose the best blue and white cookies.

What are Blue And White Cookies?

Blue and white cookies, also known as black and white cookies or half-moon cookies, are two-toned round-shaped cookies with one half coated in blue icing and the other half in white icing. These cookies are typically soft and cake-like in texture, with a hint of lemon flavor in the icing. They originated in New York City’s Jewish bakeries but have since become popular all over the United States.

Where to Buy Blue And White Cookies?

Blue and white cookies can be found in most bakeries, grocery stores, and even online retailers. However, for the best quality and freshness, I highly recommend buying them from local bakeries or specialty cookie shops. These places often make their own baked goods from scratch using high-quality ingredients, resulting in a more authentic taste.

What to Look for When Buying Blue And White Cookies?

1. Freshness: When buying blue and white cookies, it is essential to check for freshness. Look for bakeries that make them daily or within a day or two before your purchase.
2. Quality Ingredients: The quality of ingredients used can significantly affect the taste of these cookies. Look for ones made with real butter instead of margarine or shortening.
3. Texture: Blue and white cookies should be soft with a cake-like texture. Avoid ones that are hard or overly dry.
4. Flavor: The lemon flavor in the icing is what makes these cookies stand out. Make sure to taste the icing before buying to ensure it has a tangy and not overly sweet flavor.
5. Size: Blue and white cookies come in different sizes, from bite-sized to large ones. Consider what size will satisfy your craving or serve your purpose.

How to Store Blue And White Cookies?

Once you have purchased your blue and white cookies, it is essential to know how to store them properly to maintain their freshness. These cookies can be stored at room temperature in an airtight container for up to three days. If you want to keep them longer, you can freeze them for up to two months.

Conclusion

Blue and white cookies are a delicious treat that everyone should try at least once. When looking to buy these cookies, remember to consider their freshness, quality ingredients, texture, flavor, and size. By following this buying guide, you can ensure that you get the best blue and white cookies that will satisfy your taste buds. Happy cookie hunting!

Author Profile

Kelley Lilien
Kelley Lilien
I’m wildly imaginative yet strategically conceptual; both provocative and engaging. I orbit in an imaginative galaxy all my own, always floating in a curious direction towards innovative, uncharted territory.

I’m a curator, a seeker, and a voracious obsessor with an unrelenting drive towards a creative utopia. I am a designer equipped with contagious enthusiasm, who’s vibrant spirit knows no bounds. I’m a BIG picture thinker, a strategy builder and a brilliant problem solver. I believe that when passion and skill collide, magic happens.

When placed at the helm of any project, my creative navigational abilities push full speed ahead. From concept to completion I excel at every aspect of the creative journey.

Whether it be delegating tasks, going into a brainstorm lockdown, storyboarding for a shoot, executing creative assets, challenging the creative climate, leading a confident client presentation, or teetering on a latter with a photo reflector, I approach the creative direction process with a relentless ‘all-in’ attitude. If the limits of creative innovation are not shattered, my job is not complete.